Versions Compared

Old Version 19

changes.mady.by.user Nicky Hickman

Saved on

compared with

New Version 20

changes.mady.by.user Nicky Hickman

Saved on

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

TimeItemLeadNotes
5 min

  • Welcome & antitrust notice

  • Agenda review
Darrell

  • Antitrust Policy Notice: Attendees are reminded to adhere to the meeting agenda and not participate in activities prohibited under antitrust and competition laws. Only members of ToIP who have signed the necessary agreements are permitted to participate in this activity beyond an observer role.

10 5 minsIntro's new members & UpdatesAll


  • Links & References:  Please use this Responsible Tech Resources page to capture links to media or online resources that can help us with our work. Responsible Tech Resources  All are updated now
  • SSI Harms now changed on wikis, slack & calendar invites etc to BGBU
  • Our First Deliverable Storyboard, is open for business here.  Aim is to have key questions/ discussion points ready for IIW by end of month
5 minsUpdate on Actions from Previous MeetingsAll
  •  ACTION - Darrell to clone storyline format (from Drummond)
  •  ACTION - ALL to review background links (on Purpose page under Links & Files)
  •  ACTION - Persona Development
  •  ACTION - reach out to others to join or be an 'expert witness'
  • (from Drummond)
  •  ACTION - ALL to review background links (on Purpose page under Links & Files)
  •  ACTION - Persona Development
  •  ACTION - reach out to others to join or be an 'expert witness'
10 minsOskar InsightsOskar

Overview of insights from Oskar's work and blogs - where are the key gaps/issues? - perspectives on key deliverables / scope and direction for the group?

5 mins

Review of insights from previous APAC meeting

Nicky
20 minsDiscussion - Root Cause Analysis & FrameworksNicky

Root Cause Analysis?

  • Is part of the problem that many think SSI is specifically designed to address harms of Web 1.0 & 2.0?
  • Is part of the problem that SSI is designed with a specific WEIRD perspective on the nature of human identity, the format of families, marriage, kinship and naming conventions?  An ego-centric (individual)  rather than socio-centric (dividual) view of identity.?  
  • Must go deep to challenge the underpinnings of SSI - the problem of digital imperialism
    • One core under-pinning value is personal agency - this is based on principles of 'free will', this in turn is tied up with our ideas of free speech, free trade and is baked into our belief systems.  This is why it is so challenging.

Possible Frameworks:

  • Creates or uses existing framework for analysing the dangers, risks, potential harms and threats (DRiPHT) to people with a particular focus on excluded, marginalized or vulnerable people. 
  1. RIGHTS-BASED sankarshan's Digital Identifiers & Rights
  2. HARMS -BASED Me2B Alliance Digital Harms Dictionary.  Uses DJ Solove's Privacy Taxonomy or Koops et al Typology to classify digital harms
  3.  ROLES - BASED: What are the unintended consequences of SSI or digital ID benefits on our chosen persona:  Children, Refugee, Indigenous People:   e.g. McKinsey. Digital Identification, a key to inclusive growth or Kaliya Young The Domains of Identity

 Individuals use digital ID in six roles to interact with institutions and create shared value. The Domains of Identity

4. SECTOR-BASED - prioritizing the primary sectors of uptake that ToIP members want us to look at and which impact against sustainable livelihood outcomes

Healthcare

Public Sector National Identity & Legal Identification

Financial Services & Fintech

5. OUTCOMES-BASED Sustainable Livelihoods framework .  Based on the principle that your digital data is a livelihood asset, a new form of capital?  Or a digital representation of other types of capital?  Harms arise when the outcomes or consequences negatively impact positive livelihood outcomes 

  • More income
  • Increased wellbeing
  • Reduced vulnerability
  • Improved Food Security
  • More sustainable use of NR Base

More likely a combination of a couple of these?


F10 10 minsStoryboardDarrell

Outline Storyboard is here: https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1KoWjJx8LMwqNHKhAs-gK1uLdDL6zniIR/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=102748924597224658467&rtpof=true&sd=true

5 minsClose & AOBNicky
  •   

...