...
- Welcome and Linux Foundation antitrust policy - http://www.linuxfoundation.org/antitrust-policy
- Round of introductions - most of this group now knows each other well
- The group discussed the aims of the narrative group and the audience for the proposed document.
- Agreement that this must be consumable by a wide audience – policymakers, media, consumers – and cannot be too technical.
- Objectives:
- Be educational and accessible
- Provide framing/context for the materials that follow
- Respond to the concerns we see raised in the media and public debate about health passes, vaccine passports
- Walk people through many of the logical leaps that we’ve made about key design considerations and/or the best approach
- Give individuals/organizations trust that GHPC is asking all the key questions and setting the right bar for a “good” health pass.
- Marie Wallace] provided an overview of the narrative flow that she has proposed: https://drive.google.com/file/d/16hwx-CDO07bThZpT5HuaNWZovb7A4UAS/view?usp=sharing
- The group workshopped the flow, adding sections and defining action items:
- Problem statement: people want to get back to life, get back to traveling. Dan Johnson
- What does the world look like? Andy Smith
- The international air travel ecosystem is messy. A huge # of potential verifiers.
- The world is even messier when you expand to other use cases.
- Why is a health pass the right answer to this problem? [respond to the concerns we’ve heard about inequities, scientific grounding] Charles Walton
- What is a good health pass? [respond to the concerns we’ve seen about privacy] Marie Wallace
- Privacy
- Peer-to-peer
- No callback to the issuer
- What are the key design considerations? [interoperability, messiness of the ecosystem] Julian Ranger
- Pragmatic
- Decentralized data exchange
- Self-sovereign note: there was an agreement to NOT use the term self-sovereign.
- Interoperable
- Fit for purpose
- What are the technical challenges of achieving interoperability? [point to the rest of the paper and make sure the logical leaps that the drafting groups have made are clear] Rebecca Distler
- What are the recommendations and what is the path ahead for GHPC? Dakota Gruener
- Pragmatism: we’re defining what good is, but we’re not expecting perfect immediately. Certification.
- Dakota Gruener We are missing the place upfront for "what is the Good Health Pass Collaborative" to clarify why we are creating this paper in the first place. I am wondering if this should maybe come after Andy's "why is this problem so difficult?" piece, before we state our position that a "health pass" is the answer.
Resources
- Narrative Groups' Google Drive folder: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1GDkpL03rifJ89OnBfvqe96nKXMsGdkkd?usp=sharing
- If you don't have access, request it and David Luchukshould be able to help.
- Working Document: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1dWrtdrbX6Yxqzbv3AQ0CT_e2_Tx4SEUyZOdBn02ffKQ/edit