Table of Contents
absoluteUrl true

Meeting Schedule

The GSWG currently holds two bibi-weekly calls for different time zones, first is mainly for Pacific TimeZone and second for APAC TimeZone.

PT - Alternative Thursdays — 14:00-15:00 pm EDT / 15:00 - 16:00 UTC

APAC - Alternative Wednesday — 09:30-10:30 am IST / 21:00-22:00 pm PDT / 04:00-05:00 am UTC

APAC Governance Stack WG Bi-Weekly Call - Kicks off - Wednesday, 29 July 2020 — 09:30-10:30 IST/ 21:00-22:00 PT / 04:00-05:00 UTC

Send an email to governance-stack-wg@lists.trustoverip.org to request a calendar invite (you can subscribe to the mailing list at lists.trustoverip.org).

1. Welcome to attendees and Linux Foundation antitrust policy
2. New members introduction
3. Reviewing the mission of the Governance Stack WG
4. Recap of work done from EU/NA meeting - TFs, TSS, TIPs, convening of first two Task Forces
5. Open Discussion - Opportunities for APAC GSWG to contribute in existing or new TFs, Use Cases, etc. / other regional topics
6. Coordinates for the call are - https://zoom.us/j/96644380375?pwd=clhOOFRTNlNrNzBkeTV5ZHpQdGsxQT09

Thursday, 23 July 2020 — 11:00-12:00 PT / 18:00-19:00 UTC

POST-MEETING: Presentation (Google Slides) — Meeting recording

Send an email to governance-stack-wg@lists.trustoverip.org to request a calendar invite (you can subscribe to the mailing list at lists.trustoverip.org).

1. Welcome and Linux Foundation antitrust policy
2. Introduction of new members - 5 minutes
   1. Alex Tweeddale - IDWorks, London - Building decentralized stack on Corda. Has specialization with GDPR compliance
3. GSWG Leadership Updates
   1. Co-Chair /Vice Chair Announcement - 5 minutes - Scott
      1. Tom Plagge has volunteered to end his services as a Co-Chair (COVID-19 and home schooling issues)
      2. Kalyan Kulkarni would be stepping into the Co-Chair role
   2. Announcement of First GSWG APAC Call  - Kalyan Kulkarni - 5 minutes
      1. Agenda for APAC calls (see above for the agenda of the kick-off meeting)
         
         1. Please help us with outreach around the APAC call/meeting
   3. Governance Library Repository - 5 minutes - Steve Magennis
      
      1. Framework Example Library
         1. intended to help people with existing governance framework and gaining familiarity
         2. helps form concrete ideas to create deliverables
         3. if you have a framework - please contribute that and add to the Summary page
         4.  Governance Framework library would be key to gaining best practices
4. Convening our first GSWG Task Forces (Chairs & Vice Chairs—10 mins)
   1. First active TFs
      1. Governance Architecture  - Drummond - 5 minutes
         1. Will be producing the "anchor" ToIP Standard Specification for the ToIP Governance Stack
            1. will allow to measure conformance against
            2. TSS (internal, external or hybrid)
            3. Self Certification or 3rd party certification - all of these would need a TSS, which is the objective
         2. TF model allows usage of resources available to complete the planning and work towards the outcome
         3. Please refer to the ToIP Deliverables document (living document)
         4. Will be using the GitHub workflow (markdown document)
         5. How to join
            1. add name to wiki page
            2. join Slack channel (#gswg-gov-architecture-tf)
            3. mailing list coming up
            4. Meetings coming up in Sep (Drummond is on writing sabbatical through August)
      2. Process & Roles - Scott Perry - 5 minutes
         1. Complementary to the TF explained by Drummond (see above)
         2. Two aspects driving this
            1. members across a range of vantage points of the VC ecosystem
            2. who has the entire picture (the stack diagram - the concept RFC) - we need to go beyond that to build out the inventory for all the roles and processes at each layer of the stack. This will be needed by all layers
         3. We could review the existing diagram in terms of whether it is the best visual representation
         4. Existing sources can help in building the processes and roles (see slide for a representative list and Steve's Governance Framework Example Library)
         5. How to join
            1. starting next week
            2. all members announcement to be made
            3. Join Slack channel (#gswg-process-and-roles-tf)
            4. GitHub based workflow
   2. Other planned TFs
      1. Trust Assurance - Scott Perry - 3 mins
5. Ideas to Deliverables, A Trust Over IP Workflow Proposal - Steven Milstein & Sankarshan  - 15 minutes
   1. Presentation of a proposal
   2. Follow up meeting planned to work on refining the idea
      1. reach out to Steven (slack, email) for joining the meeting
6. Open Discussion / Q&A
   1. Scott Whitmire's question on Slack - is in the process of IEEE standard which may be an ecosystem of medical information. Drummond has a comment that an ecosystem can have one or more TIPs. For the L4 framework Scott is writing how much detail does he have to go? How does all this fit together?
      1. Drummond - For a L4 GF, one should be able to reference in a manner as "will rely on the following frameworks". Or, specifically set up the requirements to enable a L1 to qualify through a predefined process
7. Topics for future meetings
   1. Corda Foundation Network (Carolyne Quinn, Executive Director)
   2. Trust Assurance 101 (Scott Perry, Convener)
   3. ISO Blockchain Technical Committee (Emily Dawson)
   4. Credential Master (Timothy Ruff, Interim CEO)
   5. <Contribute/Propose name>

Thursday, 09 July 2020 — 11:00-12:00 PT / 18:00-19:00 UTC

Presentation (Google Slides) — Meeting recording

Zoom webmeetings for the NA/EU time zones alternating between plenary meetings reviewing overall Working Group and Task Force progress on deliverables and special topic meetings. In addition it supports a monthly ToIP WG update meeting for APAC timezones. See the specific scheduling details of each meeting in the sections below.

You can get a calendar invite to any meeting via the ToIP Calendar page, and Send an email to governance-stack-wg@lists.trustoverip.org to request a calendar invite ( you can subscribe to the mailing list at lists.trustoverip.org).

...

1. Ajay Jadhav - Vice Chair Technology Stack  - APAC
2. Khalid Maliki

...

.

...

...

GSWG Meeting Structure

NA/EU Plenary - Every fourth Thursday — 14:00-15:00 EDT

...

1. Communication between ToIP layers
2. More aligned to Technology Stack - GSWG not producing TIPs
3. TIP includes suite of accompanying deliverables for development and implementation support

...

1. ToIP utility layer template, building on Sovrin & others, can describe Layer 1 processes and serve as a model for other layers

...

1. Governance Layer Process Descriptions
   1. Working space: Governance Layer Processes

...

1. APAC support

...

1. Carolyne Quinn - Executive Director - Corda Foundation Network
2. Scott Perry - Trust Assurance 101
3. ISO Blockchain Technical Committee Manager - Emily Dawson

...

/ 18:00 - 19:00 UTC

Meeting recording

Send an email to governance-stack-wg@lists.trustoverip.org to request a calendar invite (you can subscribe to the mailing list at lists.trustoverip.org).

1. Welcome and Linux Foundation antitrust policy
2. Introduction of new members - 33 attendees
   1. Carly Huitema - Guelph, Canada
   2. Trevor Butterworth  - Ireland
   3. Tom Smedinghoff - Lawyer Private practice - Chicago - ABA Committee on Trust Frameworks
3. Deciding on chairs, vice chairs, and terms
   1. Chair nominees
      1. Scott Perry
      2. Tom Plagge
      3. Drummond Reed
   2. Vice Chair nominees
      1. Steve Magennis
      2. Steven Milstein
      3. Sankarshan
      4. Kalyan Kulkarni
   3. Proposed terms ("duty cycles")
      1. Proposal to have an election in 2 months
4. Presentation on machine-readable governance frameworks—Daniel Hardman
   1. https://github.com/hyperledger/aries-rfcs/blob/master/concepts/0430-machine-readable-governance-frameworks/README.md
   2. Transfer legally bound policy decisions into software functionality
   3. JSON code in example
   4. User experience  - thought experiment - Higher education - Germany
      1. issuance of digital diploma
      2. describes trust rules
      3. name and version of governance framework
      4. Burden on user side?
      5. Common metadata fields needs to be flushed out
      6. Terms of Service needs to be included
      7. Rules conveying Issuer and Verifier Assertions
      8. Could have non-conformance communicated to Governance Authority or Auditors
      9. Could include "verifying the verifier" capabilities or triggering automatic actions by an agent to perform this automatically  
      10. GLEIF records can be used to vetting entities in the process
      11. Verifiers can be excluded upon conditions
      12. A machine-readable governance framework could also automate the process of doing the "verifying the verifier" task
   5. Terms of Service can be integrated
   6. Also redress and audit
   7. A machine-readable governance framework can also be versioned like any other software, but this needs to be carefully managed so as to maintain continuity
5. Next steps on Governance Template Task Force
   1. Discussion of ToIP Work Products and Deliverables
      1. Specs and templates for joint deliverables being written - five different kinds  - to be discussed at a future meeting 
      2. TSS — ToIP Standard Specification
   2. Proposal: focus on two initial deliverables:
      1. ToIP Governance Architecture — a TSS defining the overall model and requirements for ToIP-compatible governance frameworks
      2. ToIP Layer One Utility Governance Framework Templates — a set of templates that implement the ToIP Governance Architecture for a Layer One utility
6. Topics for Future Meetings
   
   1. Scott Perry - Trust Assurance 101
   2. <your topic here>

...

See the GSWG Meeting Page template for the standard plenary meeting structure.

NA/EU Special Topic - Every second Thursday — 14:00-15:00 EDT / 18:00 - 19:00 UTC

Agenda

...

Meeting recording

1. Status since last meeting (Scott, Tom, Drummond) - 5 minutes
   1. 29 attendees
   2. New Introductions
      1. Scott Whitmire IEEE - Standard for medical Imaging
      2. Gena Morgan - GS1 - Standards in Supply Chain
      3. Will Groah IEEE working with other ToIP groups
      4. AJ Finema - Bangkok, Governance Blockchain Decentralized identity consultant
      5. Gene DiMira - Manulife - AML Compliance Officer
   3. New whitepapers, templates, thought leadership documents should be sent to Scott Perry scott@scottperrycpa.com
2. Templatizing a Utility Governance Framework based on Sovrin Governance Framework (Drummond - 15 min)
   1. Google Slides are here
   2. Sovrin Governance Framework - started in 2016, now at V2 including GDPR conformance in December 2019 - working group of over 50 members
   3. Modular Framework of documents including a Home Page, Master Document, Glossary, Legal Agreements, Controlled Documents and a Trust Assurance Framework
   4. Key best practices
      1. Modular design
      2. Must include legal agreements and legal teams
      3. One glossary for entire framework
      4. Roles and responsibilities
      5. Affiliated trust assurance framework
      6. Non-normative but accessible framework
   5. Tour of the Sovrin Governance Framework - available on web at sovrin.org
   6. Templatize the Sovrin work
      1. Tailored to Layer one but structure can be used as an overarching model for ToIP GSWG
3. Example templates from the Brighthive Repository (Tom - 10 minutes)
   1. BrightHive has focused on Data Trust (aligned to Layer 4)
   2. Governance established through a data trust agreement (DTA) - on web at  github.com/brighthive/data-trust-legal
   3. Roles and responsibilities - Better when there is a strong central authority
   4. Brighthive has examples in gitHub
   5. Framework adopted from the Intelligence Industry, Canada efforts
   6. Good examples from Goodwill Industries and the Commonwealth of Virginia
4. Open Discussion
   1. Don't Boil the Ocean - Tackle progressive steps 
   2. Next Steps - Establish your own task force
   3. Start producing Tools
      1. Standard Specification on Governance Framework Template Model 
      2. Not Layer Specific - At an Architecture Level
      3. email soliciting interest in framework architecture design
      4. email soliciting other areas that members want to tackle
5. Topics for Future Meetings - Contact Scott Perry, Drummond Reed or Tom Plagge
   1. Daniel Hardman - https://github.com/hyperledger/aries-rfcs/blob/master/concepts/0430-machine-readable-governance-frameworks/README.md
   2. Scott Perry - Trust Assurance 101

Thursday 28 May 2020 — 11:00-12:00 PT / 18:00-19:00 UTC

Agenda and Notes

See this Google Slides presentation for the full agenda. Summary:

...

1. Natarajan (Nat) Chandrasekhar – Cambridge, UK – individual contributor
2. Dan Bachenheimer – Washington, DC – Accenture Digital Identity group
3. Stu Vaeth – Boston, MA – Mastercard
4. Bryn Robinson-Morgan – UK – Mastercard
5. Arjun Govind – Philadelphia, PA (Bangalore for the moment) – Digital identity at R3
6. Catherine Nabbala – Bangkok – Finema
7. Dan Gisolfi – New York, NY – IBM
8. Elizabeth Cronan – Washington, DC – Geoguard
9. Eric Welton – Northern Thailand – Individual contributor
10. Gregor Jehle – Stuttgart, Germany – P3KI
11. Jim StClair – Mississippi – Dinocates
12. Jan Lindquist – Stockholm – Hyperledger
13. John Jordan – British Columbia – Province of British Columbia
14. Mark Lizar – Toronto, Canada / UK – Open Consent
15. Mark Scott – San Diego, CA – Individual contributor
16. Mary Lacity – Fayetteville, AK – Sam Walton College of Business
17. Matt Davies – Salt Lake City, UT – Finicity
18. Paul Knowles – Switzerland – Human Colossus Foundation
19. Robin Alexander – Vancouver, BC – Geoguard
20. Steve Magennis – Seattle, WA – Polywug
21. Steven Milstein – Montreal, CA – Collab Ventures
22. Sankarshan Mukhopadhyay – Bengaluru, India – Dhiway
23. Vinod Panicker – Kochi, India – Wipro
24. Vipin Bharathan – New York, NY – dlt.nyc
25. Wenjing Chu – Santa Clara, CA – Futureway Technologies
26. Will Groah
27. Xinxin Fan – San Francisco Bay Area, US – IoTeX
28. Chris Ingrao – Seattle, WA, US – LUMEDIC

...

1. British Columbia government challenges include digital identity of individuals, corporations, legal entities, etc. Many times, when an online service is offered, the identity field is simply treated as a freeform text field, creating serious issues with misidentification, fraud, and others. 
2. BC may lay out a set of policies at the Layer 4 level to make it clear who the recognized authorities are, in BC and elsewhere, for issuing identities (like drivers licenses). 
3. At Level 3, BC could also recognize registries for verified person credentials, permits, licenses, etc.
4.  BC might also recognize software solutions for citizens at Levels 2 and 1.

...

1. Survey of existing governance framework models
   1. E.g., FATF, Pan-Canadian Trust Framework
2. Classes of use cases and boundaries required for governance
   1. Levels of assurance that drive decisions along the stack. For example, government clearance may require high quantity and quality of sources, while employment confirmation may require less-strong assurance. Scott suggests:
      1. Untrusted class – no governance at all, status quo for the internet
      2. Internet Grade – a minimum standard of assurance with governance, a key missing piece
      3. Asset Grade
      4. Classified Grade 
   2. Need to understand use cases that government bodies might be asking of organizations such as ours. FATF example: is the digital ID system authorized by the government for use in customer due diligence (CDD)?
3. Architectural Model for ToIP governance frameworks
   1. Required, recommended, and optional components at each layer
   2. Templates at each layer
4. ToIP stack and verifiable credentials risk model
   1. See Confluence page that Scott has set up: Identity and Verifiable Credential Risks
5. Contributions to ToIP glossary

...

focused on in-depth discussion of a topic or issue affecting the GSWG community

• Emerging Trends Affecting GSWG
• Highlight of Emerging Player - Impact on GSWG Deliverables
• Future GSWG Topic or Deliverable
• GSWG Process or Tool

APAC Special Topic - To be scheduled as needed

Agenda focused on emerging topic or in-depth issue affecting the GSWG APAC community

• Emerging Trends Affecting GSWG APAC
• Highlight of APAC Emerging Player - Impact on GSWG Deliverables
• Recruiting / Aligning APAC into GSWG efforts

Index of Meeting Notes and Recordings

...

1. See organizational proposal from Dan Gisolfi

...

1. Lightweight collaboration mechanism. Can spin up at any time and last as long as necessary.
2. Minimum requirement: a wiki page.
3. Can also have mailing list, github, etc.

...

1. We elect our own. At least one, up to three (at least 2 recommended), can rotate.
2. Volunteers? (Conveners volunteer; no additional volunteers on the call, but welcome over mailing list)

...